Hello dear
Welcome To Domenico's Pizzeria
Domenico's Pizzeria, located at 26 Huckleberry Turnpike in Plattekill, NY, is a beloved neighborhood gem known for its mouthwatering food and warm family atmosphere. With a legacy spanning decades, this pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza and wings in the region, earning rave reviews from loyal customers. Favorites like the classic cheese pie and hearty chicken specialty sandwich showcase their commitment to quality. The inviting vibe makes every visit feel like a homecoming, as patron reviews attest to the welcoming service and the restaurant's ability to create lasting memories. Whether for breakfast or dinner, Domenico's consistently delivers delicious, comforting meals that keep diners coming back.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Domenico's Pizzeria
Welcome to Domenico's Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Plattekill, NY. Located at 26 Huckleberry Turnpike, this longstanding family-run establishment has served up delectable meals for decades, nurturing not just appetites but also a sense of community. With a phone call away at +1 845-566-0011, you can immerse yourself in a dining experience that pays homage to authentic Italian flavors.
Patrons rave about their unparalleled pizza, often heralded as the best in the area. The plain cheese pie, a signature offering, evokes nostalgia and comfort, as so eloquently expressed by longtime customer DeShaun. He reminisces about childhood visits and shares fondness for their Chicken Speciality hoagie, featuring a crispy, breaded chicken patty topped with melted provolone and fresh veggies. The menu is diverse, with dishes like the baked ziti dinner and a delightfully surprising chocolate chip pancake breakfast, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
What sets Domenico's apart is not just the food but the warm, welcoming atmosphere. Customers like C L emphasize the familial vibe that envelops you the moment you step inside. The community-driven spirit shines brightly, especially during challenging times, as reflected in their unwavering support for families in need. The essence of Domenico’s lies in the heartfelt connections it fosters, binding generations through shared meals and memories.
With consistent quality, fair pricing, and a menu that caters to all tastes, Domenico's Pizzeria continues to thrive as a beloved staple. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or savoring a hearty meal, you’re not just a customer; you become part of a legacy. Come for the food, stay for the friendships, and experience the love that has kept this pizzeria going strong for years. Dive into Domenico's – where every bite tells a story and every visit feels like home.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA IN THE AREA BAR KNOWN,ALWAYS READY WHEN YOU GET THEIR,EVEN WHEN EATING IN,THEFLAVOR GREAT PEOPLE AREA THE BEST,RECOMMEND THEM ,TRAVEL FROM NEWBURGH UST FOR THEIR FOOD SINCERELY DENNIS COAKLEY SR. ”
“ Great food always never been disappointed by anything they make and great prices ”
“ My dad is from NY & this is our favorite place to eat whenever we're back in NY. We took my husband for the first time a couple weeks ago & it was his favorite place that we went throughout the vacation. ”
“ BEST wings in the area, hands-down. This is a small pizzeria that's been in business for decades. It's ran by a good hard-working family. My Dad used to bring me here when I was just a pup. LOVE their plain cheese pie, too. And one of my most favorite hot sandwiches from them is their Chicken Speciality which has melted provolone with mayo, L & T on a toasted hoagie roll. The breaded chicken breast patty they use on the sandwich is really really GOOD! ”
“ My family and I have been going to Domenico's since before online reviews were a thing which is probably why I never thought to leave one. The food is always consistently delicious, my personal favorite being the baked ziti dinner or a slice with mushrooms but a very close second is the chocolate chip pancake breakfast... Yes, they make a fantastic breakfast too! But my favorite part of going to Domenico's is the warm welcome I get every time I step foot in the door. I will never forget when Domenico's made sure my family and I were well fed the night my father passed away. Domenico's is a huge reason why I love living in this small town. Walking in, feeling like part of the family and getting a great meal on top of it... Second to none! It's been great to watch the next generation take the reins too! Thank you for decades of great food and friendship! ”